“The Perfect Painless Labor”: The Natural Childbirth Movement in the Mid-Twentieth- Century U.S.”


  • Rebecca Jo Plant


This essay traces the emergence of a grassroots childbirth education movement in the 1950s U.S. and assesses its impact on women who embraced its precepts. Until thelate 1930s, when maternal mortality rates in the U.S. began to fall sharply, childbirth was widely viewed as a debilitating ordeal that entailed great suffering. But in the1940s and 1950s, as the medical profession consolidated its control over pregnancy and childbearing, a critique of standard obstetrical practices developed among a vanguard of doctors and women who advocated a return to “natural childbirth.” The key theorist of this movement, British obstetrician Grantly Dick-Read, argued thatwomen could experience “the perfect painless labor” without resorting to anesthesiaif they overcame the fear of childbirth and learned to relax their bodies. Read’s ideas found enthusiastic proponents among small groups of white, middle-class American women who established groups like the Boston Association of Childbirth Education(BACE), which prepared women for a conscious childbirth involving minimal medical intervention. Post-childbirth reports written by former students suggest that BACE equipped many students with knowledge and techniques that allowed them to derive great satisfaction from their birthing experiences. But the reports also revealhow the ideal of “natural motherhood” could establish expectations that constrained women in new and subtle ways.




How to Cite

Jo Plant, R. (2014). “The Perfect Painless Labor”: The Natural Childbirth Movement in the Mid-Twentieth- Century U.S.”. Journal of the Motherhood Initiative for Research and Community Involvement, 5(1). Retrieved from https://jarm.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/jarm/article/view/39332